-
ADDRESS23rd Floor, Building 2, Xunmei Technology Plaza, </br>Nanshan District, Shenzhen, Guangdong Province -
EMAIL512962794@qq.com -
CALL US13410701666 -
WEIXINqq512962794
发布日期:2026-05-26 16:04:42
访问量:13 A Shenzhen M&A Contract Dispute: The Full Account
Autumn 2023. The 28th floor of an office building in Futian, Shenzhen.
Attorney Sun Zheng pushed a thick stack of documents to the corner of the desk, poured himself a glass of water, and didn't drink it.
The case had been running for fourteen months since it was filed. He had handled too many disputes like this — acquisition deals that fell apart, both sides convinced they were the aggrieved party, both pushing the problem into court. But this one was different.
I. How It Started
In March 2022, a Shenzhen-based technology company ("Company A") and a Shanghai private equity fund ("Fund B") entered into a Share Acquisition Framework Agreement. Under the agreement, Fund B would acquire a 60% equity stake in the target company for RMB 420 million, payable in three tranches — the first installment of RMB 126 million due within thirty days of execution.
The agreement contained one clause that would later become the entire battleground of the dispute. Its drafting was imprecise:
"In the event of a Material Adverse Change (MAC) in the target company prior to the closing date, the acquirer shall have the unilateral right to terminate this Agreement, and any amounts already paid shall be non-refundable."
No one at the signing table had seriously mapped the boundaries of that clause. Both sides were confident the deal would go through without incident. The first installment arrived on time.
Then things started to go wrong.
II. The First Fracture
In the second half of 2022, Company A's core product line — a SaaS platform for smart commercial parks — failed to win a government procurement tender in a Shenzhen district. That project had represented approximately 22% of Company A's projected annual revenue.
When Fund B's due diligence team identified this development, internal disagreement emerged. One faction argued that losing the tender constituted a "material adverse change" sufficient to trigger the MAC clause and terminate the agreement. The other faction maintained that the loss of a single project did not meet the threshold of "materiality."
Fund B ultimately chose the most aggressive course of action: it refused to pay the second installment, sent a formal letter asserting that the agreement had automatically terminated, and requested that Company A cooperate in unwinding the transaction.
Chen Heng, Company A's founder, read the legal letter in silence for a long time. He then retained Attorney Sun Zheng.
III. Sun Zheng's Point of Entry
The first thing Sun Zheng did after taking the case was not draft a statement of claim. He read the agreement three times, then had his associate compile every judicial decision issued by Chinese courts over the past five years involving MAC clauses — eleven decisions in total, of which no more than six were directly instructive.
His conclusion was unambiguous: Fund B's legal position was difficult to sustain — but they were not without arguments to run. The deeper problem was structural. The concept of "material adverse change" occupied a genuine grey zone under Chinese contract law, lacking clear judicial interpretation. Domestic courts had not converged on a consistent interpretive approach: some decisions had borrowed the analytical framework applied to MAC clauses under common law systems; others had resolved the issue entirely by reference to the principle of good faith under the Contract section of the Civil Code.
Sun Zheng decided to build his case along two parallel lines of argument.
On the facts: Was the tender that Company A lost even reflected in the parties' material commercial assumptions at the time the agreement was signed? The answer was no. The financial projection model attached to the agreement as an exhibit had not included that project in the baseline revenue figures. Fund B's own due diligence report had not identified it as a core asset. This meant that Fund B's position — that its investment decision had been materially premised on that project — could not be substantiated on the evidence.
On the law: The triggering of a MAC clause requires that three conditions be satisfied: the adverse change must be sustained, must have a substantive impact on the target company, and must not constitute a risk generally prevailing across the relevant market. The loss of a single government procurement tender in a competitive market was an ordinary commercial risk inherent in the industry — not evidence of deterioration specific to Company A's business.
Two weeks before the hearing, Fund B changed its legal team. The incoming lead counsel was Attorney Huang — well-regarded in the profession, and an old acquaintance of Sun Zheng's.
IV. The Hearing
The case was heard before a People's Court in Shenzhen. The presiding judge was Judge Wang of the Civil and Commercial Division, known for methodical analysis and a well-developed approach to novel contract disputes.
On the first day of the hearing, Attorney Huang's strategy was to open with an information asymmetry argument. He tendered a financial assessment report commissioned by Fund B from a third-party firm, asserting that Company A had been aware of the risk of losing the tender before the agreement was signed, had withheld that information from Fund B, and had thereby committed fraudulent misrepresentation in the formation of the contract.
Sun Zheng's written rebuttal contained one sentence:
"Fund B's own due diligence firm worked on-site at the target company for forty-two consecutive days. If information was concealed, the question is: concealed from whom?"
Judge Wang looked up.
This was not a rebuttal in the conventional sense. It was a reversal of the burden of proof, executed in a single sentence, in open court.
On the second day of the hearing, the submissions converged on the interpretation of the MAC clause. Attorney Huang cited a Hong Kong court decision in an attempt to establish a comparative framework. Sun Zheng did not engage with the substance of the judgment. Instead, he pointed out directly that the decision had been decided under English law, while the agreement expressly stipulated that Chinese mainland law governed — rendering the citation fundamentally inapplicable as a matter of choice of law.
Attorney Huang was silent for several seconds.
V. Mediation
Following the close of the hearing, Judge Wang invited the parties to attempt mediation before delivering judgment.
Sun Zheng's assessment was clear. Fund B would very probably lose — but losing was something they could not afford. An adverse judgment would have visible consequences for Fund B's reputation and its ability to raise future funds. At the same time, Chen Heng needed liquidity now, not a favorable judgment five years down the line.
The two counsel spent nearly four hours in the mediation room.
The terms reached: Fund B would pay 70% of the second installment — approximately RMB 63 million. The third installment would be reassessed at the originally contemplated milestone date. The original MAC clause would be rescinded and replaced with a materially more precise triggering standard, negotiated and agreed by both parties.
When Chen Heng signed, Sun Zheng said one thing:
"Next time you have someone draft a contract, take the MAC clause out and spend half a day negotiating it on its own."
Chen Heng smiled but said nothing.
Postscript
The case never produced a public judgment. The mediation agreement is not disclosed.
But within Shenzhen's legal community, it has circulated for years as an instructive case study — not because of the outcome, but because of the moment in the hearing when Sun Zheng reversed the burden of proof on the MAC clause.
Someone once asked him: had he planned that in advance?
He said: "That line came to me the instant Huang stood up."
Behind the words of any contract lie two teams with entirely different expectations of the same transaction. What the law resolves is never simply who was right and who was wrong — it is who can turn uncertainty into a negotiable position.




