-
ADDRESS23rd Floor, Building 2, Xunmei Technology Plaza, </br>Nanshan District, Shenzhen, Guangdong Province -
EMAIL512962794@qq.com -
CALL US13410701666 -
WEIXINqq512962794
发布日期:2026-05-26 15:57:06
访问量:11 A Successful Defense: Fraud Charge Reduced to Embezzlement
What Happened
A sales employee at a private company — let's call him Mr. Li — was caught pocketing customer payments that should have gone to the company. Police investigated and sent the case to the prosecutor's office with a recommendation to charge him with fraud.
Once defense counsel got involved, though, the picture changed significantly. After a close look at the facts, the defense team argued that Mr. Li's conduct didn't actually fit the fraud charge — it was better characterized as embezzlement by an employee. The prosecutor agreed, changed the charge accordingly, and after a thorough review of the numbers, the amount attributed to Mr. Li was also reduced by over RMB 100,000. A fairer outcome all around.
Point of Defence
1. Getting the Charge Right
The whole case turned on one question: which crime actually fit what Mr. Li did?
Police had gone with fraud — the theory being that he "fabricated facts to obtain property." But the defense took a harder look and spotted a critical distinction.
Who Mr. Li was: As a company sales employee, he had legitimate access to customer funds as part of his job. That already puts him in the category of people who can commit embezzlement by an employee — a charge that requires a special relationship to the property, which fraud does not.
What he actually did: The customer payments had already come under Mr. Li's control through normal business channels. His fabrication of customer information was used to cover his tracks and buy time — it didn't cause the money to leave the company's control in the first place. That's a fundamental difference from fraud, where the deception itself is what causes the victim to hand over the money.
The prosecutor found this persuasive and changed the charge. That was the foundation everything else was built on.
2. Auditing the Numbers, Line by Line
Getting the charge right was crucial — but the amount involved directly affects sentencing, so the defense didn't stop there.
Rather than accepting the figures police had put forward, the team went transaction by transaction:
For payments allegedly withheld from customers who never paid the final installment, the defense pulled original transaction records and actual payment histories to strip out amounts that were never received in the first place.
For returned orders that hadn't been properly written off, shipping records and return receipts were used to trace exactly where the money had actually gone.
The result: over RMB 100,000 removed from the total. Not just a better number for sentencing purposes — a more accurate picture of what actually happened.
3. Telling the Full Story at Sentencing
With the charge corrected and the figures straightened out, the defense turned to building the complete picture for sentencing.
Guilty plea credit: Mr. Li disputed the original charge — but he'd been upfront about the underlying facts and cooperative throughout the investigation. The defense argued, drawing on judicial interpretations, that disputing a charge doesn't disqualify someone from receiving leniency under the guilty plea framework. The court agreed.
Restitution and settlement: Mr. Li's family repaid the full amount on his behalf, and a criminal settlement was reached with the company. The defense tied this to current judicial policy emphasizing restraint in detention and prosecution, making the case for a lighter outcome.
Personal circumstances: Medical records and household financial documents were submitted to show that Mr. Li was his family's sole breadwinner, and that the family was in genuine hardship. The defense asked the court to factor in these human realities alongside the legal analysis.
Conclusion
This case worked out because the defense didn't just know the law — they applied it carefully to the specific facts, challenged numbers that didn't hold up, and made sure the person behind the case wasn't lost in the legal argument.
Good criminal defense isn't just about citing the right statutes. It's about noticing what others miss, pushing back where it counts, and making sure the outcome reflects the full truth of the situation.




